Complete your order on EatStreet.com!

EatStreet powers the secure payment processing for Muscarella's.

Muscarella's

Order Online Now
Restaurant is currently closed.
Popular Items
. Daily Specials
Salads
  • Antipasto Salad

    Includes lettuce, tomato, onions, ham, cappicola, salami, hot peppers, black olives, green olives, mozzarella cheese & pepperoni.

    1. Small $8.99
    2. Large $10.99
  • Julienne Salad

    Includes lettuce, tomato, onions, turkey, ham & provolone cheese.

    1. Small $6.99
    2. Large $8.99
  • Tuna Salad

    Includes lettuce, tomato, onions, black olives & provolone cheese.

    1. Small $6.99
    2. Large $8.99
  • Grilled Chicken Salad

    Includes lettuce, tomato, onions, black olives & provolone cheese.

    1. Small $9.99
    2. Large $11.99
  • Steak Salad

    Includes lettuce, tomato, fried onions, mushrooms & cheddar.

    1. Small $9.99
    2. Large $11.99
  • Caesar Salad

    1. Small $4.99
    2. Large $6.99
  • Grilled Steak Caesar Salad

    1. Small $10.99
    2. Large $12.99
  • Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad

    1. Small $10.99
    2. Large $12.99
  • Chefs Salad

    Includes lettuce, tomato, onions, black olives & provolone cheese.

    1. Small $4.99
    2. Large $6.99
  • Chicken Finger Salad

    Includes lettuce, tomato, onions, black olives & cheddar, your choice of wing sauce.

    1. Small $10.99
    2. Large $12.99
Wraps
Submarines
  • Assorted Sub

    1. Half Sub $6.99
    2. Whole Sub $12.99
  • BLT Sub

    1. Half Sub $5.99
    2. Whole Sub $9.99
  • Bacon Cheeseburger Sub

    1. Half Sub $7.99
    2. Whole Sub $13.99
  • Capicola (Bison) Sub

    1. Half Sub $5.99
    2. Whole Sub $9.99
  • Cheese (Baked) Sub

    1. Half Sub $3.99
    2. Whole Sub $6.99
  • Cheeseburger Sub

    1. Half Sub $6.99
    2. Whole Sub $12.99
  • Chicken Cordon Blue Sub

    Sahlen's ham, chicken fingers & Swiss cheese.

    1. Half Sub $7.99
    2. Whole Sub $13.99
  • Chicken Finger Sub

    1. Half Sub $6.99
    2. Whole Sub $12.99
  • Fish Sub

    Only during Lent.

    1. Half Sub $6.99
    2. Whole Sub $12.99
  • Grilled Chicken Sub

    1. Half Sub $5.99
    2. Whole Sub $9.99
  • Grilled Chicken Supreme Sub

    Sweet peppers & onions or hp & onions

    1. Half Sub $6.00
    2. Whole Sub $10.99
  • Ham (Sahlen's) Sub

    1. Half Sub $5.99
    2. Whole Sub $9.99
  • Hamburger Sub

    1. Half Sub $6.25
    2. Whole Sub $11.99
  • Italian Sausage Patty Sub

    1. Half Sub $6.99
    2. Whole Sub $12.99
  • Muscarella Melt Sub

    Melted cheddar, BBQ chicken fingers, bacon, blue cheese, lettuce, tomatoes.

    1. Half Sub $7.99
    2. Whole Sub $13.99
  • Pizza Sub

    Cheese plus 1-topping.

    1. Half Sub $3.99
    2. Whole Sub $6.99
  • Royal Sub

    Sausage & cappicola.

    1. Half Sub $6.99
    2. Whole Sub $12.99
  • Salami (Hard) Sub

    1. Half Sub $5.99
    2. Whole Sub $9.99
  • Steak (Chopped Sirloin) Sub

    1. Half Sub $6.99
    2. Whole Sub $12.99
  • Steak Supreme

    Sweet peppers & onions or hp & onions.

    1. Half Sub $7.99
    2. Whole Sub $13.99
  • Steak & Sausage Sub

    1. Half Sub $8.99
    2. Whole Sub $15.99
  • Stinger Sub

    Lettuce and tomatoes on request, choice of condiments, includes chopped sirloin steak, chicken fingers and your choice of flavor and bacon.

    1. Half Sub $9.99
    2. Whole Sub $16.99
  • Tuna Sub

    1. Half Sub $4.99
    2. Whole Sub $8.99
  • Turkey (Latinas #1 Choice) Sub

    1. Half Sub $5.99
    2. Whole Sub $9.99
  • Turkey Bacon Club Sub

    1. Half Sub $6.25
    2. Whole Sub $11.99
  • Vegetarian Sub

    Includes black olives, green olives, hot peppers and cheese on request.

    1. Half Sub $3.99
    2. Whole Sub $6.99
  • "Vincenzo" Special Sub

    Assorted cold cuts & Italian sausage.

    1. Half Sub $7.99
    2. Whole Sub $13.99
  • Sicilian Pizza Sub

    1. Half Sub $3.99
    2. Whole Sub $6.99
Pizza
  • Cheese Pizza

    1. Personal 9" $6.25
    2. Small 12" $10.99
    3. Large 16" $17.99
    4. Colossal 20" $19.99
    5. Sheet (2 Large Pizzas) $29.99
  • Cheese + 1-Topping Pizza

    1. Personal 9" $7.25
    2. Small 12" $12.99
    3. Large 16" $20.99
    4. Colossal 20" $24.99
    5. Sheet (2 Large Pizzas) $34.99
Specialty Pizza
  • Chicken Finger Pizza

    Blue cheese, mild, medium, bbq or hot sauce, chicken fingers, mozzarella and cheddar (lettuce and tomato optional)

    1. Personal $9.95
    2. Small $15.95
    3. Large $23.95
    4. Colossal $29.95
    5. Sheet (XX-Large) $42.95
  • Broccoli & Cheddar Pizza

    Olive oil, 2 cheese & broccoli florets.

    1. Personal $7.95
    2. Small $13.95
    3. Large $19.95
    4. Colossal $23.95
    5. Sheet (XX-Large) $36.95
  • Steak Pizza

    Made either red (with sauce) or white (with oil & garlic), cheddar and mozzarella cheeses, onions and hot or sweet peppers.

    1. Personal $9.95
    2. Small $16.95
    3. Large $25.95
    4. Colossal $31.95
    5. Sheet (XX-Large) $44.95
  • Sicilian Pizza

    Made with 100% olive oil, fresh tomatoes, onions, Asiago cheese & spices. Anchovies on request.

    1. Personal $7.95
    2. Small $13.95
    3. Large $19.95
    4. Colossal $23.95
    5. Sheet (XX-Large) $39.95
  • The Works Pizza

    Includes cheese, pepperoni, mushrooms, sausage, onions, sweet peppers, hot peppers, black olives & green olives.

    1. Personal $9.95
    2. Small $16.95
    3. Large $25.95
    4. Colossal $31.95
    5. Sheet (XX-Large) $44.95
  • The "Hog" Pizza

    Includes cheese, pepperoni, bacon, sausage & ham.

    1. Personal $9.95
    2. Small $16.95
    3. Large $29.95
    4. Colossal $35.95
    5. Sheet (XX-Large) $54.95
  • The Hawaiian Pizza

    Includes cheese, ham & pineapple.

    1. Personal $7.95
    2. Small $13.55
    3. Large $21.95
    4. Colossal $27.95
    5. Sheet (XX-Large) $39.95
  • The Romano Pizza

    Includes Romano cheese, sauteed onions & hot peppers.

    1. Personal $8.95
    2. Small $15.95
    3. Large $21.95
    4. Colossal $27.95
    5. Sheet (XX-Large) $39.95
Calzones
Chicken Wings
  • Chicken Wings

    Choose one flavor for your wings. Single includes one dip, double and triple includes three dips, bucket includes four dips.

    1. Single (10) (2 Bleu Cheese) $16.99
    2. Double (20) (3 Bleu Cheese) $29.99
    3. Triple (30) (3 Bleu Cheese) $39.99
    4. Bucket (50) (4 Bleu Cheese) $69.99
  • Half & Half Chicken Wings

    Choose two flavors for your wings. Single includes one dip, double and triple includes three dips, bucket includes four dips.

    1. Single (10) (2 Bleu Cheese) $16.99
    2. Double (20) (3 Bleu Cheese) $29.99
    3. Triple (30) (3 Bleu Cheese) $39.99
    4. Bucket (50) (4 Bleu Cheese) $69.99
Boneless Wings
  • Boneless Wings

    Choose one flavor for your wings. Choice of 10 pieces, 20 pieces, 30 pieces, or 50 pieces.

    1. Single (2 Bleu Cheese) $11.99
    2. Double (3 Bleu Cheese) $20.99
    3. Triple (3 Bleu Cheese) $28.99
    4. Bucket (4 Bleu Cheese) $42.99
  • Half & Half Boneless Wings

    Choose two flavors for your wings. Choice of 10 pieces, 20 pieces, 30 pieces, or 50 pieces.

    1. Single (2 Bleu Cheese) $11.99
    2. Double (3 Bleu Cheese) $20.99
    3. Triple (3 Bleu Cheese) $28.99
    4. Bucket (4 Bleu Cheese) $42.99
Chicken Fingers
  • Chicken Fingers

    1. Small (5 Pieces, 2 Bleu) $13.50
    2. Large (10 Pieces, 3 Bleu) $23.99
    3. X-Large (15 Pieces, 4 Bleu) $35.99
Sandwiches
Parm Sub
  • Steak Parm

    1. Half Sub $6.99
    2. Whole Sub $12.99
  • Eggplant Parm

    1. Half Sub $5.99
    2. Whole Sub $9.99
  • Meatball Parm

    1. Half Sub $6.00
    2. Whole Sub $10.99
  • Italian Sausage Parm

    1. Half Sub $6.99
    2. Whole Sub $12.99
  • Chicken Finger Parm

    1. Half Sub $6.99
    2. Whole Sub $12.99
Side Orders
Beverages
More Pizza Options on EatStreet.com
Location
Muscarella's 5526 Main St Williamsville NY, 14221 (716) 204-9020
Takeout
Monday11:00 am - 9:45 pm
Tuesday11:00 am - 9:45 pm
Wednesday11:00 am - 9:45 pm
Thursday11:00 am - 9:45 pm
Friday11:00 am - 9:45 pm
Saturday11:00 am - 9:45 pm
Sunday11:00 am - 9:45 pm
Delivery Minimum: None
Delivery Hours: 11:00am - 9:45pm
Delivery Zones:
  • $4.00 ($10.00 Minimum)
  • $4.00 ($10.00 Minimum)
Powered by